Tuesday, June 8th, 2010

American Apparel Nail Lacquer
Summer Peach, Butter, L’Esprit, Malibu Green

American Apparel’s Summer Lacquers

Well, four of the five, at least! The lighter shades suffer from some of the same issues that the original shades did–a little streaky at first and need three coats to get a smooth, even look. The other new shade is California Trooper. Each shade retails for $6.

  • Summer Peach is a soft, almost washed out peach. It doesn’t have any pink tones to it–definitely subtle orange tones, but it’s a very, very pale peach. While I found one coat was insanely pigmented, I still ended up with three to smooth everything out, since it was a little on the streaky side.
  • Butter is exactly the color of butter. It is a soft, buttered yellow cream. Two coats here – it was easier to work with than Summer Peach.
  • L’Esprit is pastel lavender cream. Like the other shades in AA’s line-up, it’s quite pigmented in just one coat, but I found two coats were needed to give it a smoother, more even finish.
  • Malibu Green is a deep green-teal cream. This is such a beautiful shade, but it stains like no other. My nails were stained, and I had only worn this for less than a half hour. Just the residue on the cotton round I used for removal stained my other fingers a bit, too. I looked like I killed the Swamp Thing.

If you want to know more about how products are evaluated, read out Rating System FAQ! :)

  • Product: 26/30
  • Value: 8/10
  • Ease of Use: 4/5
  • Packaging: 4/5

Recommendation: These didn’t quite apply as smoothly or easily as American Apparel’s original debut, and I really wish Malibu Green didn’t stain so much–it’s truly an incredible color! I’m not completely sold on any of these shades.

AvailabilityAmerican Apparel

See more photos & swatches!

American Apparel Nail Lacquer
Summer Peach, Butter, L’Esprit, Malibu Green

American Apparel Nail Lacquer
Summer Peach, Butter, L’Esprit, Malibu Green

American Apparel Nail Lacquer
American Apparel Summer Peach Nail Lacquer (Natural Light)

American Apparel Nail Lacquer
American Apparel Summer Peach Nail Lacquer (Natural Light)

American Apparel Nail Lacquer
American Apparel Summer Peach Nail Lacquer (Natural Light)

American Apparel Nail Lacquer
American Apparel Summer Peach Nail Lacquer (Flash)

American Apparel Nail Lacquer
American Apparel Butter Nail Lacquer (Natural Light)

American Apparel Nail Lacquer
American Apparel Butter Nail Lacquer (Natural Light)

American Apparel Nail Lacquer
American Apparel Butter Nail Lacquer (Natural Light)

American Apparel Nail Lacquer
American Apparel Butter Nail Lacquer (Flash)

American Apparel Nail Lacquer
American Apparel L’Esprit Nail Lacquer (Natural Light)

American Apparel Nail Lacquer
American Apparel L’Esprit Nail Lacquer (Natural Light)

American Apparel Nail Lacquer
American Apparel L’Esprit Nail Lacquer (Natural Light)

American Apparel Nail Lacquer
American Apparel L’Esprit Nail Lacquer (Natural Light)

American Apparel Nail Lacquer
American Apparel Malibu Green Nail Lacquer (Natural Light)

American Apparel Nail Lacquer
American Apparel Malibu Green Nail Lacquer (Natural Light)

American Apparel Nail Lacquer
American Apparel Malibu Green Nail Lacquer (Natural Light)

American Apparel Nail Lacquer
American Apparel Malibu Green Nail Lacquer (Flash)

American Apparel Nail Lacquer
American Apparel Malibu Green Nail Lacquer (Natural Light)

Discussion and debate are highly encouraged, and we expect community members to participate respectfully. When asking a question, please check the FAQ section (above) for information about purchasing, price, dupes, and the like. If you have general feedback or need technical support, please contact us.

Comments that include advertisements, self-promotion, insults, etc. may be in violation of our comment policy and subject to deletion. Please see our comment policy for more information.

33 thoughts on “American Apparel Nail Polish Review, Photos, Swatches (Summer Peach, Butter, L’Esprit, Malibu Green)

  1. amy

    A stain!?!?! Oh I’m sorry Christine! Thanks for posting that. I wonder—did you use a basecoat?

  2. Vanessa

    I have to agree the green is gorgeous!

  3. Becky

    Loving Malibu Green! :)

  4. Wendy M.

    Oooh, I love them all! :D

  5. I can find similar colors elsewhere; I don’t care how good the quality of their polish is, AA is a sleazy company. Their ads are sleazy, and Dov Charney is sleazy. I wouldn’t buy anything from the company.

    • kcrystal

      is AA sleazy? I know i have bought a couple of tees from there. How are they sleazy if you don’t me asking? I know that other places such as Abercrombie, American Eagle, Guess etc … tend to have sleazy advertising .. so how does AA differ?

  6. I actually love these shades. It’s a shame the application didn’t go so smooth but that green looks lovely. :)

  7. Jennifer

    Summer peach and Malibu green and so beautiful :)

  8. amy

    I have both Butter and Malibu Green and really like both. I agree that Malibu Green stains like crazy even when I used acetate polish remover.

  9. wbwrightMakeupArtist

    Eh. If someone gifted me the Malibu, I would wear it, but thats it :(

  10. I bought Malibu Green a few weeks ago and I actually have it on right now! Although I am loving the formula of these AA lacquers, the darker colours do stain! It takes a little rubbing and some nail polish remover to eventually get rid of the stain.

  11. The green one is pretty…I liked the sleek bottles

  12. Kat

    The lavender one is super gorgeous. The last time I heard of AA nail polishes, they were having issues with toxins or whatever.

    • They weren’t, actually, having issues with toxins :( It’s really such a shame that the article that first wrote about it headlined their article as they did. AA had issues with the actual packaging – the glass – which was prone to breaking. Nothing to do with the formula.

  13. i just bought some AA polishes for the first time but haven’t used them yet. i got butter as one of them, i like it a lot! malibu is sooo pretty but i feel like the color’s not really unique, maybe china glaze’s four leaf clover is a dupe?

  14. sofia

    ooooh i really dont know which one i like most… maybe butter… but L’Esprit is so cute and malibu green is unique! i really want them all. but i’m not sure if we have this brand in greece:-(

  15. aradhana

    hey christine, excellent timing with your review…
    i just went into american apparel this afternoon to pick up tees for my husband, and i was seriously intrigued by these (and other) polishes at the cash… after reading your review and seeing the pics, i’m glad i didn’t pick up any of the pastels!

    your nails are beautiful, and as always – so are your pics, but these pastel polishes look kinda liquid paperish. i think the green is beautiful, but since you mention the staining, i think my mind’s made up!

  16. jessica

    i think i might just have to get the green one

  17. I really like the summer peach one, you apply nail polish flawlessly I can never do my own nails that nice :/

  18. Hannah

    Sally Hansen does a really similar color to Malibu Green… unfortunately it’s in their quick-dry formula which I don’t like, but the color is gorgeous (and doesn’t stain significantly)

  19. lia

    hi, im wondering if anyone can help me find a dupe for malibu green? I’ve been loking for this kind of shade for so looonggggg.. but i dont want my nails to be staineddd…

    probably from opi or china glaze or what other brand?

    thank you in advance..

  20. Luisafer

    colors are cute, but don’t like the final result…

  21. I have to agree the green is gorgeous! I like it so much!

  22. Sarah

    Great swatches Christine :) I would have loved to have seen the “Swamp Thing” hands, I like the green polish but not sure I want stained hands…

  23. Moe

    Love summer peach!

  24. kcrystal

    $6.00 each for nail polish … is a bit pricey IMO. Personally – I wouldn’t buy nail polish if it costs more than 5.00. That is my limit and im sticking to that. :) Most of the colors are dupeable anyways.

  25. Sarah

    You should do a giveaway for this set.. and pick me as the winner!

  26. Nicola

    Love butter have been looking for a pale yellow for ages. Does anyone know if any other brands do a simalar or nice yellow?? I’m in New Zealand too which sucks as we dont seem to get as many brands here.